Friday, December 03, 2021

Air Pollution is Both Local and Global

Flying Squads, Task Force: Supreme Court OKs Steps To Curb Delhi Pollution: NDTV

Air pollution is local and trans boundary. There is a limit to which it can be controlled locally, unless you have great scientific expertise. 

 If you don't have an urge for your surroundings to be clean and clear, such enforcement using police may not earn much. 

Air pollution control and management is a daily affair and never a seasonal affair.


Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Pegasus Spying: Supreme Court Orders Probe by Expert Panel

On October 27, 2021, the supreme court of India ordered that an independent expert committee will investigate the revelations made in the Pegasus spying controversy. 

The committee of experts decided by the top court will complete the probe in eight weeks. 

The following are the news sources for this story. The page will be updated later. 




Wednesday, September 29, 2021

Why Writers Need to Know About Appositive Phrases

According to the New York Public Library Writer's Guide to Style and Usage, an appositive is "a word or a phrase that identifies the noun or pronoun that immediately precedes it.". 

Appositive phrases in English language explains or identifies the nouns or pronouns in a sentence. If these phrases are not essential to the meaning of the sentence, they are separated with commas. 

Example: Amazon is launching Astro, its first household robot, powered by its Alexa smart home technology. 

But if you look at your favourite newspapers or websites, nobody cares about these rules. Appositive phrases are aplenty, set off with an opening punctuation like comma, and not closed with the same punctuation. 

"Persistent Systems founder and chairman Anand Deshpande, a newly minted Indian billionaire says being in the ultra-rich has changed nothing other than the number of people now saying that they know him," said a news story on MoneyControl.com.

The editorial desk did not see it fit to add a comma after 'billionaire'.

If the error is corrected, the sentence will be read as:

"Persistent Systems founder and chairman Anand Deshpande, a newly minted Indian billionaire, says..."

This problem of wrong punctuation is not restricted to this website. But you can find it everywhere with an alarming variations in incorrect usage.

Tuesday, August 17, 2021

Media Watch - Aug 17

 Our newspapers still contain mistakes that could have been avoided with some rechecking. 

Here's one from The New Indian Express, Bengaluru edition dated August 12. Even after five days, the same headline was seen on the web page. 


This is another one from a Malayalam newspaper Kerala Kaumudi where the chronological order on a report on the Thiruvananthapuram Airport's history appeared incorrect:



Monday, July 12, 2021

Waiting for Vaccine!

 Every day around 7.30 a.m. people start guarding the vaccine gate to salvation. In the beginning, there is discipline. 

In an hour the crowd swells and restless conversations will start. Bikes and cars roam around looking for parking space. Someone blows a whistle. People are busy talking to someone on their mobile phones. 

Sometimes, there are arguments and shouting until the 'Marshals' arrive to restrain the crowd and enforce the discipline. 


Finally the gates will be opened, they walk briskly, and the residents heave a sigh of relief. 

By 10.30 a.m. the noise and the crowd disappear and the gates remain closed as if nothing has changed. 

Sunday, February 07, 2021

Glacier break in Uttarakhand kills hundreds and damages power plants

A glacier broke off at Joshimath in Uttarakhand's Chamoli district on Sunday, resulting in floods and killing around 150 people. 

Around four power projects were damaged, bringing the focus back the concerns raised by scientists and environmentalists on the fragile Himalayan glaciers. 

 More details are waited as rescue efforts are on. 

Monday, December 07, 2020

City Images

It will take months or even years for this road dug up during the pandemic to return to normalcy. 

The hapless residents will have to put up with such constant degradation of road facilities.

Road in Bengaluru residential area dug up for pipeline works

 

Wednesday, December 02, 2020

How The Hindu Newspaper Corrected an Error!

In the 70s and 80s, school principals used to instruct students to read English newspapers such as The Hindu for improving English skills. But the last three decades had seen an erosion in the perfection of sub-editing across English newspapers in India. One can see lots of grammar and spelling errors, poor sentence structures, misleading headlines, and heavily editorialized news. 

In keeping with the highest traditions of professional journalism, The Hindu had issued a correction to an error that I pointed out on Twitter on Dec 1, 2020.  

On its front page, a news story had an error about the end date of the current Assembly term in Karnataka. Instead of 2023, the news story mentioned the year as 2013. A silly mistake. 

A paragraph in The Hindu newspaper with incorrect text marked in red.

On Dec 2, The Hindu on page 4 published a correction. 

A page in The Hindu Newspaper showing a correction to previous day's news item.

But the same story on the newspaper's online edition (accessed on Dec 2, 10: 50 am IST) had a different text. The edit made created a grammatically weak sentence at the end of the respective paragraph. This poor sentence remains unedited on Dec 2. 

An image of The Hindu newspaper's web page with highlighted text.


Tuesday, December 01, 2020

Three Types of Mutations in SARS-COV2 Virus Infections

In a paper, No evidence for increased transmissibility from recurrent mutations in SARS-CoV-2, published in the Nature Communications journal, the authors state that none of mutations identified lead to the increase in the spread of Covid-19. 

This definitely is good news. 

The paper also lists three ways in which the SARS-CoV2 virus mutates in infected humans:

  • Mistakes in copying errors during the replication (multiplication) of the virus.
  • Interactions with other viruses in the affected human cells.
  • Changes in the host RNA modification systems.

The paper says that out of the identified total of 12,706 mutations, about 398 strongly supported recurrent mutations were observed. It also added that the genomic diversity of the virus remains low, but vigil should be maintained continuously.

Wednesday, November 04, 2020

10 Steps to Reduce Air Pollution in Bengaluru

If you think air pollution can be controlled by maintaining the status quo, then you are probably mistaken. Pollution is linked to our day-to-day activities. It is the stark reality.

In Bengaluru, the primary reason behind air pollution is that there are lots of vehicles on the road, especially during peak hours. The more vehicles that you add to the existing number, then the air pollution will keep on increasing. 

Air pollutants do not vanish overnight. They stay in the air and they will react with other chemicals to form toxic compounds that create eye irritation and respiratory issues. If night temperatures are less, the chemicals trapped in dense air will disappear next day only. 

To reduce air pollution in Bengaluru, do the following:

Reduce the number of vehicles

This is the saddest and the most controversial solution that nobody will agree to. There are over 83 lakh registered vehicles in Bengaluru, says a report in the Deccan Herald newspaper. The city has to reduce its vehicle numbers. Reduce the number of diesel vehicles whether they are private cars, cabs, buses, or lorries. 

Phase out old vehicles

Discard vehicles that are old and polluting than the rest. Allow only healthier old vehicles to remain with stringent anti-pollution standards. Allow exceptions based on well-defined criteria. For example, the poor and farmers may need some exceptions. 

The traffic police authorities can also cancel the registrations of vehicles against which more than three grave traffic violations have been reported. If the violations are more than five, consider sending these vehicles to a local reuse and recycle economy to provides jobs to local people. 

Cap vehicle registration

Consider a quarterly or annual cap on vehicle registrations. Link vehicle registrations with air pollution levels. For example, if quarterly air quality data exceeds the defined levels, stop or slow down registrations. Consider an annual cap on SUVs. Make this process transparent. 

Revamp fuel policy

Review the fuel policy and ensure that you move towards greener, less polluting fuels. Stop adulteration of fuels on a war footing. Start a helpline to let citizens to report fuel adulteration. Set milestones on how you will achieve this. 

Improve public transport

Strengthening public transport is the universal solution for air pollution control. But public transport stacked with hundreds may not be ideal. Encourage suburban railway networks with good bus connectivity to inner areas. Don’t leave commuters stranded at railway stations. 

WFH

The Covid-19 lockdown has proved that working from home does work. It can be the new normal and not a reluctant exception. Encourage work from home or work from anywhere policies among trusted employees. Provide incentives to employees who use public transport more than private vehicles. 

Create cycling lanes

Another universally recommended solution to curb air pollution. But perform a pilot health study before you create cycle lanes. High temperatures, poor roads, heavy traffic, suspended particulate matter (SPM), and air pollution pose risks to cyclists. 

Regulate diesel generators

Even residential areas are not free from loud diesel generators contributing daily to the particulate matter pollution in the city. Daily power supply disruptions are the primary reasons why these generators are widely used. 

Develop a green construction policy

Bengaluru needs a sustainable construction policy whether it is for residential areas, high-rises, office space, or for the metro trains. There is tremendous air, water, and noise pollution from construction activities in the city. There is nobody to regulate the pollution caused by construction activities. The levels of noise and dust pollution caused by bore well digging is unimaginable in any other modern city.  

End solid waste burning

Burning of solid waste on the streets is very common. Residents realise only when the acrid smell reaches their nostrils. Residents can play a big role in stopping this practice by forming neighbourhood teams to report such violations to the authorities. 

Thursday, October 22, 2020

What is FSD?

FSD stands for Full Self Driving. The term is famously associated with US-based electric vehicle company, Tesla.

So, you have FSD software and FSD cars. 

The Verge reported that Tesla released their FSD Beta software to a select number of users. The report says that the Beta release "...will enable drivers to access Autopilot’s partially automated driver assist system on city streets. The early access program is used as a testing platform to help iron out software bugs."

Meanwhile Elon Musk had tweeted that he "Will be extremely slow & cautious, as it should."



Saturday, September 19, 2020

Indian News Media and Fallacy of Expert Opinion and Arguments

 I am not a big fan of India's prime time debates, especially those by the so-called national media. I still scour the print media for news and editorial views and social media for comments (both valid and stupid). 

To me, most of the prime time debates are just one-sided cacophony and in a democracy like India these unprofessional conduct should have been regulated and punished long back. It may be the case that as a trained journalist, I can research more on the fare dished out and check facts and fake news by all forms of news media. 

Such a luxury may not be available to all viewers and they then become the primary victims of targeted propaganda through social media. 

Against this background, I was not at all surprised at the belligerence in which the anchor at NDTV was shouted at by an 'expert'. The discussion was about the booming stock market amidst a tanked economy and a pandemic. 

Stock markets are not the best indicators of an economy. So it is ridiculous to consider stock market variations as an evidence of the health of the economy. And investors are not the 'real' experts that the media should be inviting for debates on economy and issues of farmers. 

In every channel, one can see such 'experts'; some are called 'political observers'. What exactly is this 'political observer' and what is the criteria for dubbing someone as a political observer. In India, everybody has an opinion on anything under the sun. In that vein, a man on the street is also an observer. 

How many poor people have you seen, except in times of tragedies or natural disasters, in TV studios? How many poor farmer leaders have you seen in prime time debates? How many poor workers, who left the cities following the lockdown, did you see on these national television studios? How many reporters interviewed them, except for suitable sound bytes for ground reports? How many environmentalists did these channels feature in their discussions? 

Since we all know that the answer is No, then how can we expect these news media to serve as the Fourth Estate? There is no discretion in including 'experts' in prime time discussions on Indian news channels. To 'balance' the debate, channels include political spokespersons and 'independent' spokespersons who support a party. 

But the biggest problem is including rich or successful people as experts when they are actually 'political operatives'. In the past, we have seen investors, advertisement professionals, the so-called activists, corporate honchos, and actors in news studios who are actually willing partners in the larger political script and propaganda. 

When you don't practice discretion in including experts, when you try to 'balance' opinion by inviting political operatives. there is no debate, but cacophony. The viewer's right to facts gets thwarted here and it just becomes absolute waste of time and energy. 

So, go back to newspapers, talk to people that you know, learn to perform your own research, abandon prime time discussions, and say no to fake news and propaganda. Indian democracy and your world will be much much better. 

Tuesday, July 21, 2020

Oxford Vaccine Trial and the Indian Press

News about the promising results from the vaccine against Covid-19 developed by Oxford university created some buzz in the India media. The news was flashed from July 20 evening after the university itself broke it. 

The study was published by the medical journal Lancet. The vaccine - called ChAdOx1 nCoV-19

The BBC said the vaccine produced antibodies and T-cells that can fight Coronavirus in the 1077 patients tested. It also added that the vaccine is made from a genetically engineered Chimpanzee virus that can cause infection similar to Coronavirus and can trigger antibodies and T-cells to counter the virus.

The Times of India added an Indian perspective and reported that the "Serum Institute would seek regulatory approval for clinical trials of the vaccine in India. 

The Indian Express as usual had an explainer that compared and listed the vaccines that were under development worldwide. 

Overall the Indian press looked bullish about the preliminary results of the Oxford vaccine trial and hoped that in 6-8 months the vaccine may offer the much needed succor to many. 

Friday, July 17, 2020

Big Win for Privacy as European Court of Justice Invalidates EU-US Data Shield

The European Court of Justice's order yesterday striking down the EU-US Data Protection Shield in the Schrems II case is a big win for European privacy activists.

The court, according to Techcrunch, ruled that the US surveillance laws and data protection supposed to be provided in the EU-US Data Protection Shield"...interference with the fundamental rights of persons whose data are transferred to that third country”. The portal also states that because of this ruling "more companies (may) switch to regional data processing for European users".

Austrian privacy activist and lawyer, Max Schrems, had approached the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) to suspend Facebook’s use of standard contractual clauses SCCs. The data regulator took him to court and later Irish judges referred the case to Europe’s Court of Justice, which delivered this order.

CNN reported that around "5000 US companies rely on for transferring information across borders" and they will be now affected with the ECJ order.

BBC said that "Affected companies will now have to sign standard contractual clauses, as per EU laws.

As privacy activists celebrate the ECJ ruling, can India learn anything from this?

Thursday, July 16, 2020

Twitter's Blue Tick Bitcoin Hack Raises Alarms

I searched Facebook posts also when I heard that the Twitter accounts of several blue-ticked celebrities and the rich were hacked.

BBC reported that the Twitter accounts of "Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates are among many prominent US figures targeted by hackers in an apparent Bitcoin scam". A message was also posted seeking Cryptocurrency donations to these accounts.

In an explainer, The Indian Express reported that "the Bitcoin wallet promoted in the tweets received over $100,000 via at least 300 transactions."

The Hacker News carried a speculation that "that hackers grabbed control of a Twitter employee's administrative access to take over a prominent account and tweet on their behalf".

Jack Dorsey's message about the hacking of verified accounts in Twitter

If this the method used, then it is a very disturbing news. And it also raises questions about at whose all behest can an employee 'take over' another account. Can authorized company personnel do it on the company's behalf or can a state agency make such a request?

Wednesday, July 15, 2020

Google Faces Lawsuit Over Data Privacy

A day after Google announced its big five-year plan to invest Rs 75,000 crore in India, most of the newspapers splashed stories on the latest suit against the search giant.

Google faces lawsuit over tracking in apps even when users opted out, was the headline in Indian Express. Its story talked about the latest data privacy violation suit slapped by the law firm Boies Schiller Flexner, against data collection even after users had turned off “Web & App Activity” tracking and when in Incognito mode. Looks like the same Reuters copy was published in leading news sites such as News18, Livemint and Times of India also.

Google snippet shows stories on Indian newspapers on the latest lawsuit
Add caption

Interestingly, a piece in The Print tried to lay out why the tech giants are turning to India. From self-reliance to helping the battered banking sector and the ready mobile payments ecosystem, this piece provided hints on where the proposed investments may end up or prove beneficial. Let us keep our fingers crossed.

But it does not ponder over whether "...Information collection, analysis and distribution is exactly what the U.S. internet companies do best" could pose data privacy problems for digitally illiterate users in a nation where a data privacy law has not yet been passed. 

Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Google Announces Rs 10 Billion Fund in India

Google's plan to invest $10 billion in India has created lots of buzz in the tech, government, and industry sectors.

The Times of India says that Google will work in areas as diverse as 'affordable access to information in local languages', 'building products', 'digitizing businesses', and applying 'tech and AI' areas like 'health, education and agriculture'.

Livemint says the proposed fund will be raised through a 'mix of equity investments, partnerships, operations, infrastructure and ecosystem investments'. The announced projects include tie-ups with CBSE, Prasar Bharti and a 1 million grant to Kaivalya Foundation.

The Indian Express added that the proposed investments will also be made through projects such as Internet Saathi and the AI-based flood forecasting system. A Techcrunch report details the education projects Google already have in India.

Overall, the reporting was bullish about the proposed investment by the tech giant in India. But, both the Times of India and The Hindu Business Line raised questions about data privacy and data collection by global tech giants such as Google, as India is yet to enact a strong data protection and data privacy law. Times of India also raised concerns about 'digital monopoly quoting Mohandas Pai.

It remains to be seen how the Indian state governments and the start-up ecosystem respond to Google's forays into sectors such as education and blended learning. Also of interest will be how the anti-trust laws against Google elsewhere will have an impact in India and how the legal system will respond to similar suits in India.

Also, the entry of big tech cos into controversial sectors like health, education and agriculture might face some opposition from social activists and farmer's unions.

Meanwhile, the press reports did not have much to say on Google's plans in the health and agriculture sectors.

Friday, June 26, 2020

PM2.5 and Air Pollution in Bengaluru

A report in Bengaluru's Deccan Herald today says that "...Air pollution in Bengaluru dropped by an average 28% during the Covid-19 lockdown".The report cites a study on PM 2.5 levels that decreased during the lockdown as an indicator of air quality improvement.

It is not scientific to conclude that a decrease in one air quality indicator (AQI) results in overall air quality improvement or reduction in air pollution. This is because PM2.5 is just one AQI parameter used to measure the air quality level in India. Other pollutant levels need to be tracked to know whether their levels have decreased or not. This include Ozone, oxides of Nitrogen, Sulphur Dioxide, PM 10, and Ammonia. 

A report by the Centre for Science and Environment says that Ozone levels saw a spike in many cities that were supposedly clean during the lockdown. The same report states that Bengaluru had an average PM2.5 level of 45% during the lockdown and NOx level have increased by 38%. This further casts doubts on the data quoted by Deccan Herald. 

The Deccan Herald report also does not state the pre-lockdown level of PM2.5 in Bengaluru and the new reduced levels. 

Most importantly, there was a partial lockdown in Bengaluru from March 13, whereas the data is quoted from March 23 when a full lockdown was imposed in the city. That, I feel. can lead to erroneous data. 

Friday, June 05, 2020

3 Things to Think About the Environment Today

It’s is yet another World Environment Day and the world is in lockdown because of Covid-19. While all of us care about the environment, there are three issues that are worth pondering over today.

Governance: Some say that the main beneficiary of Covid-19 pandemic has been the environment. During the period of complete lockdown in India, the air quality was better and the noise levels were less. Social media users posted pictures of how they could see faraway mountains from their terraces, as the thick brown haze disappeared from the skies.

But still things are not that rosy. We are still unhappy that despite nearly 30 years after the famous Rio Summit, our rivers remain polluted, forests are being destroyed, wild animals are being killed, and life in cities and villages are becoming difficult. Why is this so?

What we are missing is strong and scientific Environmental Governance. Just like the anti-corruption charade, environmental protection has now become annual one-day affair. Our legacy governance systems remain the same and awareness has not transitioned to action. This is not to say that there have been no improvements so far, but the record has been patchy and non-uniform.

Lack of transparency and accountability still leads to knee-jerk reactions and damage control operations at times of crisis. Decisions based on scientific logic and expert advice seem to be lacking even now.

A kite perched amazingly on top of a tree branch in Bengaluru
A kite perched on top of a tree in Bengaluru
Dichotomy: A small and influential section of our population still consider environment and development as opposites. This has resulted in environmental rules and regulations and the spirit of environmental protection as yet another hurdle in project clearance. The bureaucracy and pollution control boards don’t have the time to enforce environmental protection rules, but as mere departments to approve or reject project proposals. 

Development and environment are not polar opposites. Both are inextricably linked to each other and it’s time that alternative developmental paradigms are considered and implemented.
Time for Nature: I don’t think that we can go back to a pre-history life wandering in the forests. But we must understand that it is Nature that has provided human beings with the optimum conditions to thrive and flourish.

We still seem to not comprehend our deeper connections and continuity with the self-organizing natural system. It’s time that we embed Nature at the centre of our mind, and remove our egos. It’s time for us to understand and act responsibly, and desist from thinking that we have an unquestionable right to plunder and devastate the environment.

Newspaper front pages - June 5

 Some images of front pages of newspapers after votes were counted on June 4, 2024 after a ridiculously long parliament elections.  Did the ...